Windrush: missing papers and the burden of proof

Trace the Story Back

Z · Finished outcome

2018 public scandal and 2020 review · United Kingdom. Independent review, testimony and policy history.

12 · Build

Wendy Williams’s review examined how government policies and practices harmed members of the Windrush generation, including people whose lawful status was difficult to prove under documentary demands.

3 · Flip and clear

A person’s inability to produce a requested paper is treated as proof that they had no lawful status.

6 · Integrate

Reconstruct the distinction between a person’s rights, the papers they had, and the state record the decision-maker checked. List which of those actually supports the official action.

9 · Verify

Check the record: UK government · Wendy Williams’s Windrush review — https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/windrush-lessons-learned-review · UK government · independent historical research — https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-historical-roots-of-the-windrush-scandal. Record what would change your conclusion.

A · Show what made it work

QI · What did you figure out?
Record your evidence and the step that changed the result.
QE · Can someone else use what you learned?
Teach the step. Ask what was confusing and show what you changed.

Open the companion activity

Proof sheet

What I made or found:

How I checked it:

What a second person could repeat: