Z · Finished outcome
1881 and 1957 · Tombstone, Arizona, and Hollywood. Location documented. Conflicting accounts and film dramatization preserved.
12 · Build
The fight occurred in a vacant lot off Fremont Street near C.S. Fly’s premises. Later writers popularized the corral label and a 1957 film brought it to more audiences.
3 · Flip and clear
The title is used as a literal location. A dramatized duel or a partisan account is treated as proof of who did what.
6 · Integrate
Put the lot, the stable and the movie on separate lines. The next-day headline was Yesterday’s Tragedy. Compare a map, accounts of the preliminary hearing and the later title.
9 · Verify
Check the record: U.S. Census Bureau · historic map and account — https://www.census.gov/geographies/reference-maps/1881/comm/tombstone-az.html · Cochise County Historical Society — https://www.cochisecountyhistoricalsociety.org/journals/cchs-vol-11-no-01-spring-1981.pdf · American Film Institute · 1957 film — https://catalog.afi.com/Catalog/moviedetails/52199. Record what would change your conclusion.
A · Show what made it work
- QI · What did you figure out?
- Record your evidence and the step that changed the result.
- QE · Can someone else use what you learned?
- Teach the step. Ask what was confusing and show what you changed.
Open the companion activity
Proof sheet
What I made or found:
How I checked it:
What a second person could repeat: