DINE and the confident wrong turn

Trace the Story Back

Z · Finished outcome

Contemporary · search and generative AI. Context error supported by the supplied exchange. Intent unestablished.

12 · Build

In the supplied exchange, a query about DINE was answered as a restaurant request despite the existing subject. The example can be checked against the conversation sequence.

3 · Flip and clear

The confident answer or a later explanation is accepted without checking what had already been said. A context error is automatically classified as deliberate deception.

6 · Integrate

Record the claim, the earlier context and the observable error. Preserve the original transcript privately and give the source for any new factual claim. Run the same context test against any AI, including Nathan AI.

9 · Verify

Check the record: NIST Generative AI Profile · confabulation — https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/ai/NIST.AI.600-1.pdf. Record what would change your conclusion.

A · Show what made it work

QI · What did you figure out?
Record your evidence and the step that changed the result.
QE · Can someone else use what you learned?
Teach the step. Ask what was confusing and show what you changed.

Open the companion activity

Proof sheet

What I made or found:

How I checked it:

What a second person could repeat: